Home insurance from several insurers, in one form

A broker puts your home and contents to several insurers and places the policy you pick. With Gary that’s one online form: we look the property up from the address, the insurers price it side by side, and a real broker places it.

Gary on the front path of a 1970s brick home, leaning on the letterbox

Why compare home insurance quotes

Insurers price the same house differently, and you only see that when several of them quote it at once. In 11 test quotes run through our form between August and October 2026, the dearest insurer’s price was 1.05 to 3.2 times the cheapest for the same answers. In 8 of the 11, the gap was more than half the cheaper price.

Price isn’t the only difference. Three home wordings on our panel, read side by side:

Paid over the building sum insured if the rebuild costs more
10%, 25% or 30%, each on its own conditions
Jewellery and watches, per item, unless you list them
$5,000 or $10,000
How long the home can sit empty before cover narrows or stops
60, 90 or 100 days

A broker shows you those differences and arranges the policy you choose. When you claim, the insurer runs it, and we’re there if it gets stuck. Renting it out? Landlord insurance is quoted the same way.

One home, three pricesOct 2026

A house in Victoria, building insured for $1,047,000, the same answers to every insurer. Annual price from each, including GST and stamp duty:

Insurer A
$3,059.44
Insurer B
$4,449.71
Insurer C
$5,247.80

A test quote through our own form; insurers unnamed because the panel changes. Your price depends on your home and your answers. Median gap across all 11: 1.7×.

What building and contents cover

Building is the house and what’s fixed to it; contents is what you’d take with you if you moved. Both together, on one policy, is the combination most owner-occupiers on our panel are quoted for.

Owner-occupiers here; renting it out is landlord insurance. Renters’ contents is on the list; ring us in the meantime.

BuildingCon­tents

Walls, roof, floors and the rest of the structure

BuildingCon­tents

Fitted kitchens, built-in wardrobes and fixtures

BuildingCon­tents

Fences, sheds and garageslimits often apply

BuildingCon­tents

Furniture, clothes, electronics and appliances

BuildingCon­tents

Carpets and curtainsbuilding in some policies, contents in others

BuildingCon­tents

Somewhere to stay while it’s repairedfor a set period, as each PDS says

BuildingCon­tents

Spills, knocks and breakagesthe accidental damage tier, where offered

BuildingCon­tents

A guide, not a policy. Every insurer’s PDS sets out exactly what it covers, and we link it beside every price.

What home insurance is for

What each part of a policy responds to. Your quote shows which apply at the tier you pick. Rented out? Unpaid rent and tenant damage are landlord insurance.

A pipe lets go in the wall

Escape of liquid · listed events

Sudden water damage from a burst pipe or appliance. Slow leaks are treated differently; the PDS says how.

Hail through the roof

Storm · listed events

Storm, hail and rain damage, on each insurer’s definitions. Flood is defined separately, and we link every PDS.

Someone forces the back door

Burglary & theft

What was taken and the damage done getting in. Locks and an alarm are part of the price.

The saucepan gets away from you

Fire · listed events

Fire and smoke damage to the house and to what’s in it.

Paint on the new carpet

Accidental damage · a higher tier

Spills, knocks and breakages that listed events don’t reach, where you choose the accidental damage tier.

You rent it out

Landlord policies

The building, and the contents you provide, on a policy written for rentals. What it pays for around tenants differs; the PDS sets it out.

How to get a quote

A brass front-door key with a wooden house-shaped fob

Tell Gary about the place

Start with the address. We look the property up, so you’re not guessing at floor area or the year it went up.

A 1970s typewriter

The insurers price it

Each one rates the same answers. Where a policy comes in tiers, you see them side by side, whole.

A stack of manila folders

A person places it

You pick and pay; a broker places the policy and your documents arrive by email.

Gary with a clipboard on the sandstone steps of a grand Federation home

High-value homes

When the building is insured for $3 million or more, the same form also goes to a specialist insurer for high-value homes, whose underwriters look at each home themselves.

  • It comes back as a referral, and a broker brings you the underwriter’s price
  • Other insurers on the panel quote beside it where their limits reach
  • Same form as every other home

Where each insurer’s limit sits, and what a $4.5 million house cost to insure: luxury and high-value home insurance.

What the form asks

Intake sheetabout ten minutes

The address
and what’s there, which we look up
The build
walls, roof, floors, year built, storeys
The sums
what to insure the building and contents for
The excess
what you’d pay first on a claim
Security
locks, and an alarm if you have one
The history
claims in the last few years, plainly

Nothing you don’t have to hand. If we already know it, we don’t ask.

Worth checking before you buy

What does a home insurance broker do?

A broker puts your home to several insurers, shows you what each one charges and covers, and arranges the policy you choose. When you claim, the insurer runs the claim; the broker is there to help if it gets stuck. A broker acts for you, where an insurer’s own staff act for the insurer.

Does a broker cost more than going direct?

There’s a broker fee, currently $50 a year on a Gary home policy, shown on the quote before you buy, and the insurer pays us a commission out of its premium. In the test quotes run through our form, the gap between the cheapest and dearest insurer for the same home was usually far larger than the fee.

Is a broker the same as a comparison site?

No. A comparison site generally refers you on to an insurer, which then sells you the policy. A broker arranges the policy itself and stays your point of contact through renewals and claims. Gary quotes online like a comparison site, and a real broker places the policy.

Who decides the sum insured?

You do. You nominate what the building would cost to rebuild and what the contents would cost to replace. Each insurer’s PDS explains how they apply it at claim time, and it is worth reading before you settle on a number.

Does a higher excess lower the premium?

Usually, and the other way round. The insurers set minimums; if you pick below one, the quote comes back at their floor and says so, rather than being quietly declined.

Am I covered for flood?

Whether flood is covered, and what counts as flood rather than storm or run-off, differs between policies. It is written down in each PDS, and we link to them with every quote.

Why did I get “referred” instead of a price?

Certain addresses and building types are priced by an underwriter rather than the computer. When that happens we come back to you with the underwriter’s figure, not a guess.

Is this advice?

Everything here is general information only. It doesn’t consider your objectives, financial situation or needs. We explain how home insurance works and show what households commonly choose; read the PDS and decide what fits.

Related pages

Quotes from several insurers

Homes are priced by several Australian insurers, with a specialist insurer for homes of $3 million and more. Each quote names its insurer, links its PDS, and shows what the premium includes and how we’re paid, in writing rather than in the fine print.